Epidemiology, Causes and Outcome of Burns in Women From Southern Iran: 2009-2011
Women's Health Bulletin: June 16, 2014, 1 (2); e20123
June 11, 2014
Article Type: Research Article
March 17, 2014
March 27, 2014
April 10, 2014
G. Epidemiology, Causes and Outcome of Burns in Women From Southern Iran: 2009-2011,
Women Health Bull.
Burns are among the most prevalent mortality causes in developing countries, particularly Iran. In addition to large treatment expenses, burn victims suffer from long-term physical and psychological injuries.
This study intends to recognize the epidemiologic factors, causes and outcome of burns among hospitalized women in the Burn Wards of Ghotbeddin Hospital in Shiraz, Iran.
Patients and Methods:
This was a cross-sectional study carried out for a period of 2.5 years. The population consisted of all women hospitalized in the Burn Wards of Ghotbeddin Hospital from March 2009 until September 2011. Patients' information was entered in a checklist using old records and documents after which the collected data were analyzed by SPSS software version 15.
A total of 619 women were hospitalized over a 2.5 year period due to burns. Their mean age was 25.78 ± 17 years with a range of 3 months to 103 years. Approximately half of the burns (45.4%) occurred at home, most of which (35.0%) occurred during the spring season. Kerosene was the most prevalent cause of burns (30.0%). Of these, 210 (33.92%) women were referred due to self-immolation; familial disputes were the main cause (46.6%) for these referrals. There were 232 (37.48%) cases whose deaths were attributed to burns and its complications during this period.
Annually, many women have been admitted and treated in burn hospitals, which result in tremendous financial expenses, physical deformities, psychological disabilities and mortality. Therefore, public education of burn prevention measures seems to be necessary.
Copyright © 2014, Health Policy Research Center, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits copy and redistribute the material just in noncommercial usages, provided the original work is properly cited.
The injuries attributed to burns comprise 5%-37% of morbidities and mortality in developing countries (
1). Pain that results from burns, the long treatment process and physical deformities from the burn scars on the one side and large treatment expenses ( 2), On the other hand cause long-term physical and psychological disabilities among patients, particularly women ( 3). Although the worldwide census of mortality attributed to burns has declined, a large difference is still observed in the mortality rate and resultant organ defects from burns among different countries ( 4). In America, the mortality rate among women with burns has declined from 7000 cases in the year 1970 to 2500 cases in 2004. No exact census of burn rate in Iran is available but it is estimated that at least 1% of women suffer from accidents caused by burns annually. Out of this rate, 3.4% (approximately 13000) must be hospitalized and, on average, at least 10% die due to the severity of their injuries and resultant complications. According to a 2000 WHO published census, the rate of burn mortalities in Iran has been reported to be 4.8 per 100000 persons the third global rank after India (8.3 per 100000) and Africa (5.5 per 100000) ( 5). Improvement in prevention plans ( 6) and pre-hospital care, management of intensive care wards and equipping burn hospitals, the rapid removal of injured tissues ( 7) and the use of skin grafts ( 8) are among factors that assist in reducing the burn mortality rate in developed countries. In Shiraz as well as many other cities in Iran, pre-hospital care is not available. Thus patients' wounds will practically remain open and exposed to various environmental infections from the time of the accident until the victim arrives at the hospital. Sometimes patients' relatives put different contaminated materials on the wound that could be potentially dangerous ( 9). In many cases the burned person is taken to crowded treatment centers, thus potentially increasing the risk of infection. The Ghotbeddin Hospital in Shiraz is the only therapeutic center allocated for burn treatment for Fars and some of the southern neighboring provinces. In addition to the population of other provinces, for the 2000336 women in Fars Province this hospital has the capacity to admit only 25 women.
Therefore, considering the importance of burns in women and the necessity of having an exact census of the rate and outcome of burns, we conducted this research to study the epidemiology, causes and outcome of burns among women during the years 2009-2011 at Ghotbeddin Hospital in Shiraz, IR Iran.
3. Patients and Methods
The present study is a retrospective, descriptive research carried out using the files of all women who suffered from burns during the period March 2009 to September 2011 who were hospitalized and treated at Ghotbeddin Hospital. The data collection tool consisted of a two-part questionnaire that included demographic characteristics (first part) and the information connected with burn patients (second part). This questionnaire was evaluated and confirmed by ten faculty members of the Nursing and Midwifery College of Shiraz and Yasouj, a city in Iran, from the view point of content validity and reliability via test re-test (r = 0.8). Of note, in order to prepare this questionnaire we applied the help of a similar tool used by Afrasiabi et al. in their research, “Studying the Causes Connected with Burns among Patients Hospitalized at the Burn Ward of Shahid Beheshti Hospital of Yasouj City” (
10). We began the data collection process after obtaining permission from the Research Assistant at Hazrat-e-Fatemeh Nursing and Midwifery College of Shiraz and presenting an introduction letter to the aforesaid hospital. After receiving approval, we extracted the necessary information from medical files of the hospitalized women in order to complete the questionnaire. After injured patients were admitted to this hospital, initially the burn percentage was determined by Wallace’s rule of nine. If necessary, venous restoration was performed according to Parkland’s formula. After stabilization of the patient and application of the primary dressing, the patient was transferred to the ward. Dressings were usually changed once per day and a sample obtained from the wound for culture once upon arrival to the hospital, after which sample collection was repeated weekly. Wide spectrum antibiotics (ciprofloxacin and metronidazole) were administered and, in case of observed signs of infection, patients received other medicines (amikacin and imipenem). The treatment outcome was classified as patients who were treated and discharged, died or were transferred to the provinces with better equipped centers where the patients did not need to be accompanied by an attendant. Collected data were analyzed with descriptive statistics and SPSS software version 15.
During this study 619 women with various burn injuries were hospitalized. The age range of patients was between 3 months to 103 years with a mean age of 25.78 ± 17 years (
Table 1). Approximately 146 (23.59%) girls below 12 years of age were hospitalized primarily due to burns from boiled water or other hot liquids. Most burns (81.5%) occurred at home with cooking as the most common activity ( Table 2). It was reported that kerosene (30.0%) was the most prevalent cause of burn ( Table 3). There were 210 (33.92%) women hospitalized due to self-immolation, 83 of which were single and 114 were married. In these patients familial disputes were the main cause for self-immolation in 98 cases (15.83%) ( Table 4). Most patients (64.7%) were housekeeper ( Table 5). Most burns (35.0%) occurred during the spring season ( Table 6).
Table 1. Frequency Distribution According to Age in Women With Burns
Age, y Burned Women ≤ 1 8 (1.3) 2-12 146 (23.6) 13-19 80 (12.9) 20-29 175 (28.3) 30-39 88 (14.2) 40-49 43 (6.9) 50-59 37 (6.0) 60-69 12 (1.9) 70-79 19 (3.1) ≥ 80 11 (1.8)
aData are presented as No. (%).
Table 2. Frequency Distribution of the Location of Burn Accidents
Place of Burn Burned Women Home 506 (81.5) Work 71 (11.4) School 5 (0.7) Car accident 19 (3.6) While playing 18 (2.8) Total 619 (100)
aData are presented as No. (%).
Table 3. Frequency Distribution of the Cause of Burn Incidence
Cause of Burn Results Kerosene 209 (33.8) Gas 125 (20.2) Hot instruments 97 (15.7) Gasoline 105 (16.9) Electricity 24 (3.9) Firewood 8 (1.3) Inflammable substances 2 (0.3) Chemical substances 2 (0.3) Steam 1 (0.2) Others 21 (3.4) Not recorded 25 (4.0) Total 619 (100.0)
aData are presented as No. (%).
Table 4. Absolute and Relative Frequency Distribution of the Cause of Self-Immolation
Cause Results Familial dispute 98 (46.6) Marital problems 3 (1.4) Economic problems 6 (2.9) Consumption of narcotics 13 (6.2) Psychological problems 49 (23.3) Other cases 16 (7.6) Unknown 25 (12.0)
aData are presented as No. (%).
Table 5. Absolute and Relative Frequency Distribution of Occupational Status of Women With Burns
Occupation Results Housekeeper 401 (64.7) Self- employment 56 (9.4) Worker 43 (7.0) Student 42 (6.7) Unemployed 38 (6.0) Farmer 39 (6.2) Total 619 (100.0)
aData are presented as No. (%).
Table 6. Frequency Distribution of Burns in Various Seasons of the Year
Season Results Spring 208 (33.5) Summer 88 (14.1) Autumn 195 (31.4) Winter 128 (21) Total 619 (100)
aData are presented as No. (%).
From the education point of view, 102 (21.56%) cases were illiterate, 255 (53.91%) had an education equal to the ninth grade level, 84 (17.76%) had a diploma and 32 (6.76%) were educated above the diploma. There were 139 (22.45%) residents of Shiraz, 19 (3.07%) were villagers, 435 (70.27%) were residents of other cities in Fars Province and 26 (4.20%) were referred from other states. Most (35.0%) were housewives. Regarding the burn severity, 109 (17.61%) had second degree burns, 73 (11.79%) had third degree burns and 437 (70.59%) cases had burns with different degrees. In connection with the burn extent, 213 (34.41% had burns of less than 25%, 296 (47.82%) had burns of 25.0%-50.0% and 110 (17.77%) had burns of more than 50.0%. From the view point of burn outcome, 232 (37.48%) cases died from burn injuries and the resultant complications. Of these, 11.0% of the total mortality belonged to girls below 12 years of age. There were 6 (0.97%) cases transferred to other states and the treatment results for 29 (4.68%) cases were not recorded.
In the present research, 619 burned women were hospitalized and treated in Ghotbeddin Hospital, Shiraz over a 2.5-year period. This figure approximated the reported census from similar studies in Iran but was higher compared to the global census. Roozbahani et al. in an epidemiologic study in Esfahan reported that 446 women with burns were hospitalized at Imam MousaKazem Burn Hospital during a period of one year in 2003 (
11). According to reports by Kabirzadeh et al. 612 women with burns referred to the Zare Education- Treatment Center in Sari during 2002-2004. This study included hospitalized as well as out-patients ( 12). Also, Aghakhani et al. reported the number of hospitalized women in 2005 at Imam Khomeini Hospital in Oroumieh to be 310 ( 13). The above studies showed a lower census of the numbers of burned women. Mashreky et al. has reported the burn census in Bangladesh during the year 2003 to be 723 women ( 14). Burn injuries are among the most important causes for hospital admission; age and sex are also among the important epidemiologic criteria for burn injuries. In the present research, young women between 20-29 years of age comprised the highest numbers of burned women. The results of a study by Afrasiabifar et al. on burn causes among hospitalized patients of both genders at Yasouj Hospital showed that most burned patients (60.6%) consisted of women between 10-19 years of age ( 10). Meantime, the results showed that, 23.59% of burns and 11.0% of mortalities were seen in girls below the age of 12 years. In this respect, the result of a research in Nigeria has also shown that the incidence of burn (23.6%) occurred in girls less than 10 years old ( 15). According to Afrasiabifar et al. 24.0% of burn cases were girls less than 13 years old ( 10). Therefore, it could be said that the results of the present study from the view point of burn prevalence among young children was similar to the results of other studies. In connection with the burn season, the results indicated that most (35.0%) burns happened during the Spring season which contradicted the results of other studies in Iran ( 11, 16). The reason might be attributed to completion of sampling in September 2011, so the rate for burns in the Fall and Winter were not calculated, which could have impacted the results. Furthermore, the first month of spring(Farvardin) is the month of bon firing and accidental burns. So, this could be interfere with total results.Kerosene was the most prevalent (30.0%) cause of burns. Kerosene is still used by many people in most parts of the country, particularly in Fars Province as a cheap material to produce heat which in turn increases the risk of fire and subsequent burns. The majority of self-immolation cases were related to young married women (55.34%), low literacy (83.71%), village residents (79.33%) and kerosene (73.40%). In this regard, the results of a study by Mashreky et al. “The Rate of Burn Resultant Mortality in Bangladesh”, reported the maximum number of self-immolation cases belonged to villager women with low literacy ( 14). Meantime, familial disputes (46.6%) and the existence of psychological disorders (23.3%) have been mentioned as the main causes for attempted self-immolation. A study by Mohanty et al. conducted from 1993-2003 in connection with the rate of self-immolation that resulted in mortality in India showed that 79.5% of self-immolation cases belonged to young women who were 21-30 years of age. Injuries sustained from their husbands and financial poverty were among the main causes for self-immolation ( 17). Ahmadi et al. reported that over 70.0% of attempted self-immolation cases in Iran suffered from a type of psychiatric disorder ( 18). Obtaining such results might be an indication of requiring more attention to the matter of consultation, the necessary education regarding life skills and patient screening so that it might be effective in reducing the rate of attempted self-immolation. These results were in line with the results of the current study. In this study, there were 232 (37.48%) mortalities attributed to burns. Towfighi et al. Reported that 52.4% of hospitalized women in the Burn Ward of Shahid Motahari Hospital in Tehran died due to injuries sustained from burns ( 19). According to Mashreky et al. ( 14). The number of mortalities was reported to be 18 out of 1381 (23.8%) cases of hospitalized patients. Anyway, in different studies inside Iran, the women mortality rate related to burn was almost similar but this rate increases when compared to global census. Hence, it can be said that burns are one of the most disastrous events followed by increased mortality, creation of severe complications such as deformities, loss of normal functioning, and increase in the incidence of psychiatric problems. Fortunately these tragic events are largely controllable by the use of proper education of medical personnel in the treatment of burn victims, correct application of oil-burner instruments, and observation of safety points in addition to the establishment of equipped, adequate therapeutic centers. Therefore, educating the public about burn prevention measures is necessary. There were some study limitations. First, the reliability of administration data was typically constrained by the fact that the data was collected at various time points with a potential for time lag and accurate reporting of the exact hospital admissions. Second, this study was a cross-sectional research. Therefore data on women who did not seek medical attention or who attended a health-care facility were not available for our analysis. Although perceived to be relatively small number of burn injury cases, this numerical gap might have caused us to under-estimate the true incidence of burn victims in Shiraz. Our findings show no significant changes in burn hospital admissions or deaths over a 2.5 year period. We believe this could be attributed to variations in the success made by the government and health care agencies in burn injury prevention and control programs as well as variations in efficient treatment and clinical practices amongst primary care providers. Therefore, educational efforts for prevention should be the keystone to minimize the incidence of burn injuries.